Creepypasta Lost Media

I like pasta because they taste good

Oh yeah i remember "drawing" (tracing) that one creepy Yoshi image when i was young, i thought it looked cool and didn't mind much

I'm glad seeing it resurface again :D!

PLEASE stop censoring sensitive words, YouTube barely gives a fuck about people who swear or say sensitive words nowadays

The original dog for Smile Dog was found way longer ago than that because I remember seeing it in 2020, but I'm glad that the other components have been found. I'm fairly certain it's the image from the blog instead of the stock image because of the way the teeth are crowded. I always thought the stock image wasn't quite right.

Not a creepypasta, but I would love for you to cover “Scaredey Camp”, from the early 2000s on Nickelodeon. It was short lived as a series but got me into horror early on.

The music gives me nostalgia for when Mutahar used to read creepypastas

Nah. This thing still unsettles me to this day. 24:36

19:30 I also found a “music” group called “I shot the duck hunt dog” where they have the cover of Yosi with no arms eating Mario but I will not recommend checking out their music because it’s awful like your ears will bleed

Lol, SomeOrdinaryGamer Creepypasta reading theme 🙂‍↔️

Oh my god I remember reading the Dancer story when it was posted. I even remember reading a comment to the effect of “typical big brother behavior” LMAO

Coral

The one user's username Paul Sheldon comes from Stephen King's Misery.

suicidemouse has one piece of lost media I can’t seem to find.

When watching some different iterations of it, typically at the very end it cuts to black, then shows a clip of a robed figure walking into a dark room. I remember back in the day Kitty0706 (RIP) called him Bill Clinton. Allegedly it comes from a short called propagation666, but I can’t find the exact clip it’s meant to be. I also never understood why the clip was there to begin with, but it’d be interesting to find the OG

Good video. Thank you for reading we danced, creepy pasta

9:30 this is probably my favorite creepypasta for whatever reason it really disturbed me

Notice how none of these are the episodes from Lost Episode pastas? 🤔

speaking of lost creepypasta stuff i remember reading a lost creepypasta myself too or at least i think it's lost since i can't find it since i do remember the creepypasta's name surprisingly it was called Mr. Red and from what i could remember since i didn't finish the story since it was pretty long it was about this guy aka the narrator who used to watch this show called Mr. Red it was kind of like those shows like Barney where the main character was in a mascot costume and had friends like Ms. Red and i do think a few of other friends that Mr. Red had which was a frog an owl and a mouse and the narrator said that the children would make random cameo's making answers to questions or something like that since i guess it was an educational show and the narrator said there where rumor's about something bad happening behind the scenes with the children and there was also a villain named Mr. Blue i don't remember what he did but the only way to stop him was using math and the narrator had a Mr. Red themed birthday party with people in Mr. Red costume and the grandma had a heavy box filled with Mr. Red vhs tapes some where official and some were bootlegs and i guess one day the narrator deiced to watch a Mr. Red episode using one of the vhs tape that he got for his birthday and you guessed it the episode had spooky stuff in it and it do remember one of the characters in the show i think it was the frog looked at the screen and started to blink as morse code i couldn't remember what the morse code said cause i don't think the narrator said what the morse code said in English and i remember where the narrator was planning to grab the remote to stop the episode but for reasons i don't remember he decides to keep the episode playing and later in the story the narrator falls down the stairs and lands on a Mr. Red plushie which I'm pretty sure he meant the toys that are kind of those robotic Elmo toys where some would laugh and some would walk yeah that Mr. Red plushie was kind of like those in the story and when the narrator turn the plushie on it walked up to him and said something i couldn't remember and that's all i could remember from the story i did notice someone on YouTube made a creepypasta reading on Mr. Red the DVD which i think it was the sequel if anyone remembers this creepypasta please reply on anything else you remember about this creepypasta

26:59)
Bait used to be believable...

It stayed lost media and finally now it's found ok
The story I'm talking about is Cameraheads

I always thought cameraheads was such a cool idea.

I haven't heard that background music in YEARS.

I love when scary music is used in these types of videos and iceberg videos so much. It adds so much more to the vibes

It is very unfortunate what we now associate camera heads with

Bro the stupid “teddy bear” picture had me so jacked up back in the day

Fuck, still no Seedbutter x Sourcebrew yaoi.

YAAAAAAAAAAAAAASSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!

the werewolf one reminded me of a documentary i saw years ago about wereteens (or teen werewolves). there are still a lot of videos from that community from 10 years ago that are still on youtube

The original smiledog.jpg source image you showed was the false one, the original creator of the red image has shown the original unaltered photo, it was a template of a husky meme that clearly had much more resemblance towards.

You should’ve covered Shadow Readers lost 2017-2019 narrations

Yeah yes my favourite brother Sourcebrew has bring creepypasta and iceberg again really nostalgia with the others👍🏻😎

The only reason why i know the teddy creepypasta was becuase of coryxkenshin reading the story about it

Ihsoy is crazy boy

Is it just me or is the whole Jeff the killer thing the cringiest fucking thing ever

The resident evil 4 sound

What about the original rake image.

It cannot be the Resistance game enemy.

Back in 2015, I saw a german Animal Crossing creepypasta on Youtube. The story was more or lass that the protagonist shut down the game resetting it over and over and over until Resetti eventually dies. The player notices that Resetti is no longer there and checks. The player sees every villager with pixelated faces and black eyes. They surround a grave with a decidation written for him (I no longer remember) and RIP, while the song "K.K. Dirge" played in the background. The player got horrified, turned off the game and threw away the cartridge or something like that. Yeah, it sounds generic, but that´s I remember it. but can´t recall more details. The video was made by a small german channel and narrated by a girl. However, I can no longer find the video or the creepypasta itself. The most similar I can find is the one in the link below, but it was written in 2022 and contains some differences. Maybe it was inspired by it, who knows?
https://creepypasta-wiki.de/animal-crossing-new-leaf-resetti-tod-creepypasta/

I know stuff like Jeff's original photoshop image still being lost media as far as I know, but stuff like ENTIRE stories becoming lost is honestly kinda creepy... maybe even a bit pasta too.

CameraHeads are also in Watch_Dogs

9:54 I got so scared until I realized cp stood for creepypasta

15:58 that stock image is definitely the one used on the smile dog image. Look at the gaps in the teeth, they're identical.

The spanish speaking youtuber the killer slash has the most info about the Teddy (actually he started the search) check It out please

Just finished the video. No Rake image?

The Teddy image whigs me out at a glance. But for some reason, it creeps me out less the longer I look at it.

I remember seeing these images back in the day, I was a huge creepypasta fan, early 2010 times were such a good time for horror on YouTube, and many other forms of content

Can we stop using "coded"? Its such a cringe term.